JANUARY
Optimism Abounds on Wall Street This New Year
Investors’ Hope for 2024: Just a Normal Year
More Than 70 Killed at Memorial Service for Iranian Commander
Google is Killing Cookies. Advertisers Still Aren’t Ready
Hiring Accelerated With 216,000 Jobs Added Last Month
Wanted: College Presidents. Mission: Impossible
Elon Musk Has Used Illegal Drugs, Worrying Leaders at Tesla, SpaceX
Buying Home and Auto Insurance is Becoming Impossible
China Becomes World’s No. 1 Auto Exporter – With Help From Russia
When Washington Calls on Biden to Fire People, He Usually Says No
Inflation Edges Up After Rapid Cooling in Most of 2023
Citigroup to Cut 20,000 Jobs
Ron DeSantis’s Big Bet on Iowa Risks Not Paying Off
Haley, Making Modest Gains in Iowa, Has Eye on New Hampshire
As Iowa Prepares to Vote, Focus is on Who Places Second
After Iowa, Trump Sets Sights on New Hampshire, Haley
China’s Population Decline Accelerates
Biden Accedes to Tougher Stance on Immigration
A Hot Debt Market is Slashing Borrowing Costs for Riskier Companies
Nikki Haley’s Last Hope for Beating Trump Rests With These Voters
Stocks Are at Record Highs, but Things Will Get Harder From Here
Underdog Haley Gets One-on-One Race With Trump
Trump and Haley Face Off in New Hampshire
Trump Rolls to Victory but Struggles With Independents
Economy Grew 3.1% Last Year, Defying Recession Fears
World Court Rejects Demand for Gaza Cease-Fire
Get Ready for the Longest White House Race Ever
S&P 500 Rallied to Records on the Back of Just One Sector
Intelligence Reveals Details of U.N. Agency Staff’s Links to Oct. 7 Attack
23andMe’s Fall From $6 Billion to Nearly $0
FEBRUARY
On the High Seas, a Pillar of Global Trade is Under Attack
Hiring Accelerated With 353,000 Jobs Added Last Month
Iran Condemns U.S. Airstrikes as Washington Signals Further Action
U.S. Plans Further Action Against Iran’s Militia Allies
Big Tech Stocks Have Little Room for Error After Monster Run
Why the FAA Still Can’t Fix Boeing
Senators Race to Save Ukraine Aide as Border Deal Fails
How the Rockefellers and Billionaire Donors Pressed Biden on LNG Exports
Biden’s Age Back in Focus After Special Counsel Report, Verbal Flubs
Biden Has More Than an Age Problem. Voters Don’t See Him as Presidential.
Elon Musk Isn’t the Only Billionaire Fighting Delaware
How China Miscalculated Its Way to a Baby Bust
Inflation at 3.1% Reflects Stubborn Pricing Pressure
U.S. Probes Israeli Strikes That Killed Civilians in Gaza
Biden-Netanyahu Relationship at Boiling Point as Invasion Looms
Alexei Navalny, Putin’s Most Ardent Critic, Dies in Prison
Alexei Navalny’s Death Marks the End of Political Dissent in Russia
Trump Fraud Ruling Threatens to Curb Family Business
America’s Oil Power Might Be Near Its Peak
SpaceX Forges closer Ties with U.S. Spy and Military Agencies
U.S. to Invest Billions to Replace China-Made Cranes at Nation’s Ports
Nvidia’s AI Boom Electrifies Markets
Nvidia Surpases $2 Trillion Valuation
Can Warner Bros. Uncancel J.K. Rowling?
How a Shifting AI Chip Market Will Shape Nvidia’s Future
Nvidia Has Become Silicon Valley’s Hot Employer
Haley Defiant as Campaign Braces for Blowout Loss in Michigan
Should Big Pharma pay poor countries for finding new diseases?
SEC Investigating if OpenAI Investors Were Misled
MARCH
Musk Sues OpenAI and Altman, Saying They Abandoned Founding Mission
Everything is Going Trump’s Way – Except Financially
Voters Are More Upbeat on Economy, but Biden Gets Little Benefit, WSJ Poll Shows
JetBlue Scraps $3.8 Billion Takeover of Spirit Airlines
Haley’s Fate on the Line as Super Tuesday Kicks Off
Nikki Haley to Exit Republican Presidential Race
China Intensifies Push to ‘Delete America’ From Its Technology
U.S. Hiring Boom Continues With 275,000 Jobs Added
In Battleground States, Trump is Ahead in Polls but Playing Catch-Up on the Ground
Biden Warns Netanyahu a Rafah Assault Would Cross ‘Red Line’
It Isn’t Just Big Tech Propelling Gains in the Stock Market Anymore
Inflation Picks Up to 3.2%, Slightly Hotter Than Expected
House Set to Vote on TikTok Ban as Lobbyists Turn Attention to Senate
Mnuchin is Putting Together a Group to Buy TikTok
The Rough Years That Turned Gen Z Into America’s Most Disillusioned Voters
The New Rules of Home Buying in a Changed Market
Fed’s Challenge: Has It Hit Brakes Hard Enough?
Goldman Executive Joins Exodus of Top Female Staffers
Realtors Reckon With a Seismic Shift in How They Get Paid
Trump Claims 2024 Will Be Rigged, Putting Republican Turnout at Risk
U.S. Sues Apple, Alleges Tech Giant Exploits Illegal Monopoly
Trump is in a Race Against Time to Protect His Wealth
Death Toll in Attack at Russian Concert Hall Tops 110
Johnson Can’t Run House Without Democrats’ Help
Boeing CEO Dave Calhoun to Step Down in Wake of 737 MAX Struggles
Baltimore Bridge Collapses After It Was Hit by Ship
The Night Shift on a Baltimore Bridge That Turned Deadly
FTX Founder Sam Bankman-Fried Sentenced to 25 Years
Evan Gershkovich. One Year Stolen. – A year in Russian prison. A year stolen of stories, stolen joys, stolen memories. The crime: journalism.
These Eight U.S. Bridges Are Vulnerable to a Repeat of the Baltimore Crash
U.S. and Israel’s ‘Unprecedented’ Intelligence Sharing Draws Criticism
APRIL
Stocks’ Magnificent Seven is Now the Fab Four
Israel Says Strike That Killed Seven Gaza Aid Workers Was Unintentional
Biden’s Approach to Gaza Angers Both Sides at Home
How Disney’s Bob Iger Vanquished Wall Street Agitator Nelson Peltz
Hiring Accelerated With 303,000 Jobs Added in March
Return of Gazans to North Emerges as a Key Issue in Cease-Fire Negotiations
In Six Months, Everything Has Changed for Israel
Doubts Creep In About a Fed Rate Cut This Year
The Black Market That Delivers Elon Musk’s Starlinks to U.S. Foes
Hot Inflation Report Weakens Case for Fed’s June Rate Cut
Fed Rate Cuts Are Now a Matter of If, Not Just When
Israel Wins Gaza Battles but Risks Losing the War
U.S. Moves Warships to Defend Israel in Case of Iranian Attack
Israel Says It Thwarted Drone and Missile Attack by Iran
Tesla to Cut More Than 10% of Global Workforce, Musk Tells Staff in Email
Israel’s War Leaders Are Deeply Divided
Emboldened Iran Makes Dangerous Gamble on Open Confrontation
Inside Amazon’s Secret Operation to Gather Intel on Rivals
Israel Strikes Iran in Narrow Retaliatory Attack
VW Workers Vote to Join UAW in Historic Southern Win for Union
Inside the White House’s Scramble to Avert Full-Blown Middle East War
Move Aside Banks: Giant Funds Now Rule Wall Street
U.S. Takes Aim at China Banks Aiding Russia War Effort
The Folly of China’s Real-Estate Boom Was Easy to See, but No One Wanted to Stop It
U.S. Economic Growth Slowed to 1.6% in First Quarter
Blinken Meets With Xi as U.S. Pressures China to End Support for Russia
Investors Cheer AI Spending Boom in Big Tech – Just Not at Meta
Star Scientist’s Claim of ‘Reverse Aging’ Draws Hail of Criticism
Wall Street’s Home-Buying Spree Faces Crackdown
Fed to Signal It Has Stomach to Keep Rates High for Longer
MAY
Federal Reserve Interest-Rate Decision Looms
Fed Chair Projects Optimism Despite Stubborn Inflation
U.S. Hiring Slowed to 175,000 New Jobs in April
Activist Groups Trained Students for Months Before Campus Protests
Baby Boomer Professors Join Protests, Risking Arrest, Violence
Columbia Cancels Main Graduation Ceremony After Weeks of Protests
Israel Seizes Key Crossings as Truce Talks Intensify
Chaos on Campus, in Gaza, Threatens Biden’s Campaign
Biden’s Threat to Freeze Weapons Deliveries Raises Alarm in Israel
Corporate America Is Sitting Out the Trump-Biden Rematch
As Biden Loses Latinos to Trump, Arizona Democrat Wins Them Over
There’s Not Enough Power for America’s High-Tech Ambitions
Investors Crowd Into Soft-Landing Trade Ahead of Inflation Data
Flood of Fake Science Forces Multiple Journal Closures
Inflation Eases as Core Measure Hits Lowest Level Since 2021
Russian Spacecraft Tested Components for Antisatellite Weapon, U.S. Says
Trump Allies for Unprecedented Crackdown on Immigration
Trump Is Rarely Silent, but Testifying Would Be ‘Really Dangerous’
Iran Says Helicopter Carrying President Is Missing After ‘Difficult Landing’
Iran’s President, Top Diplomat Killed in Helicopter Crash
The Highest Paid CEOs of 2023
The EPA Cop Who Became a Warrior for ‘Forever Chemicals’
Nvidia is Booming. Here’s What Could Slow It down
Behind the Scenes of Scarlett Johansson’s Battle With OpenAI
Inside Rockefeller Clan’s Intensifying Feud With Exxon
Tech Workers Retool for AI Boom
Anxious Democrats Want Biden to Show More Empathy on the Economy
Israeli Tanks Close In on Central Rafah as Uproar Grows
Mexico is About to Elect Its First Female President. Her Job: Save the Nation
How America Inadvertently Created an ‘Axis of Evasion’ Led by China
Trump Guilty Verdict Rocks 2024 Presidential Campaign
JUNE
Biden Stakes Re-Election Campaign on Reviving Bad Memories of Trump
Elon Musk and Jamie Dimon Are Making Peace
The Opaque Investment Empire Making OpenAI’s Sam Altman Rich
Merrick Garland, Three Special Counsels and a DOJ Under Fire
Americans Have More Investment Income Than Ever
Is This America’s First $100 Million-a-Year Athlete?
Hiring Trounces Expectations, With 272,000 Jobs Added
Four Hostages Rescued From Gaza, Israel Says
Israel’s High-Risk Hostage Rescue, Blow by Blow
The Unlikely New Real-Estate Darling: Restaurants
Apple Intelligence: A Guide to Apple’s AI-In-Everything Strategy
Elon Musk’s Boundary-Blurring Relationships With Woman at SpaceX
WSJ Reporter Deemed Wrongfully Detained Is Indicted Under Russian Espionage Laws
Macron’s Gamble on Stopping Le Pen Now Risks Ushering Her to Power
Top CEOs Are Flocking to Trump Again in Bid to Shape Agenda
Investors Fear Long Stretch of Calm in Markets Can’t Last
Corporate Tax Rate Spurs Political Fight With Over $1 Trillion at Stake
Social-Media Influencers Aren’t Getting Rich – They’re Barely Getting By
At $25 Each, Cigarettes Are Turning Gaza Aid Trucks Into Targets
For Apple’s AI Strategy, China is a Missing Piece
Home Prices Hit a Record High
We Bought This Bread in April. It Still Looks Fine.
GOP Plan for Democratic Convention: Bash Chicago as a Mess
Ukraine’s Naval Drones Turn the Tide in the Battle of the Black Sea
U.S. Ambassador Accuses China of Undermining Diplomacy
Biden Wants to Be Tough With Russia, Iran – But Wants Low Gas Prices Too
The Shadowy Judicial System That Controls the Fate of WSJ’s Evan Gershkovich
Democrats Discuss Replacing Biden on Presidential Ticket
As World Saw Biden Deteriorate, Democrats Ignored It
Democrats Worry Biden’s Debate Performance Hurt Down-Ballot Hopes
JULY
17 Years, $700 Million Wasted: The Stunning Collapse of New York’s Traffic Moonshot
Satellite Images Show Expansion of Suspected Chinese Spy Bases in Cuba
Democratic Unity Cracks in Wake of Biden’s Debate Performance
Biden Moves to Shore Up Support as Democratic Unity Cracks
U.S. Economy Adds 206,000 Jobs as Hiring Stays Strong
Iran’s Voters Elect Their First Reformist President in Two Decades
France Votes in Decisive Round of Parliamentary Election
Insurers Pocketed $50 Billion From Medicare for Diseases No Doctor Treated
How Biden’s Inner Circle Worked to Keep Signs of Aging Under Wraps
High-Tech American Weapons Work Against Russia – Until They Don’t
Milder Inflation Keeps Doors Open to September Rate Cut
Biden Seeks to Shore Up Campaign, Halt Defections
Biden Buys Campaign More Time but Pays a Steep Price
Trump Survives Assassination Attempt. Suspected shooter, who was killed, had explosives devices in his car and used a gun registered to his father.
Trump Shooting is Stunning Failure for Secret Service
J.D. Vance Offers Trump a Fresh Face With a MAGA Profile
Musk Turbocharges Silicon Valley Support for Trump
Top Democrats Close in on Biden as Plan to Sew Up Nomination Falters
Evan Gershkovich Sentenced to 16 Years in Russian Prison After Wrongful Conviction
Trump Dominates Convention and Unites GOP as Democrats Splinter
Inside the Trump Campaign’s Hidden Ground Game
How the Bet on Joe Biden Turned Into an Epic Miscalculation
Harris Glides Toward Nomination, Contest With Trump
Israel’s Netanyahu Confronts Altered Political Landscape in Washington
U.S. Economy Grew at Brisk 2.8% Rate in Second Quarter
Sabotage Hits France’s Rail Lines as Olympics Begins
Democrats Bet America is Ready to Elect a Black Woman President
A Fed Interest-Rate Cut is Finally Within View
Venezuela’s Maduro Declares Victory in Disputed Election
Investors on Alert for September Rate Cut Signals
Killing of Israeli Foes Puts Mideast on Brink of Wider War
AUGUST
Israel Says It Killed Hamas Military Chief in July Strike
Inside the Secret Negotiations to Free Evan Gershkovich
Lousy Jobs Figures Force Fed to Reckon With Hard Landing
Widespread Benefits of Tight Job Market Are Now at Risk
Stock Futures Fall as Global Selloff Intensifies
Harris Picks Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz as Running Mate
Disney Post First Streaming Profit, Warns on Theme-Parks Business
Sinwar Power Grab Cements Hamas-Iran Ties
Trump’s Plans Stir Fears for Fed Independence
Race is On to Reach the Rapidly Shrinking Pool of Undecided Voters
Medicare Opioid Limits Didn’t Protect This Doctor’s Patients From Deadly Overdoses
Investors Borrowed Like Crazy During Rally. Now They’re Paying the Price.
Starbucks Ousts CEO, Names Chipotle Boss as Replacement
Cooling Inflation Sets Stage for September Rate Cut
A Drunken Evening, a Rented Yacht: The Real Story of the Nord Stream Pipeline Sabotage
Harris to Call for Expanded Child Tax Credit, 3 Million New Housing Units
Harris and Trump Propose Divergent, Costly Panels for Taming Inflation
Sam Altman’s Worldcoin is Battling With Government Over Your Eyes
Inside Kamala Harris’s Enormous Fundraising Drive
Food Industry Pushes Back on Harris’s ‘Price Gouging’ Plan
Ford Cancels Plans for Electric SUV, Expects to Take $1.9 Billion Charge
Home Sales Rebounded Modestly in July
Fed Chair Powell Declares ‘Time Has Come’ for Rate Cuts
The West’s Next Challenge is the Rising Axis of Autocracies
Trump Steps Up Campaigning to Counter Harris’s Momentum
After Hezbollah’s Retaliation, All Eyes Fix on Iran
Harris’s Tax Cuts, Hikes Take Shape
The American Dream Feels Out of Reach for Most
U.S.-Made F-16 Fighter Jet Crashes in Ukraine
PCE Inflation Holds Steady in July
Americans’ Modo on the Economy Brightens – a Bit
SEPTEMBER
American-Israeli Among Six Hostages Found Dead in Gaza
Israelis Go on Strike Amid Fury Over Failure to Secure Hostage Deal
Two Ukrainian Top Guns Lobbied for F-16s. They Won’t Get to See If the Jets Help Fend Off Russia.
Nasdaq, Oil Prices Edge Lower
Trump to Adopt Musk Proposal for Efficiency Commission
Hiring Improved a Bit in August With 142,000 Jobs Added
Repeated Takes, Coaching on Lines: Inside Hamas’s Hostage Video Machine
Trump’s Problem in Michigan: A County Where Republicans Can’t Get Along
September is Once Again a Tough Month for Stocks
What to Watch for in the Trump-Harris Debate
Inflation Extends Cooling Streak, Hitting 2.5% in August
Wall Street Curbs Young Bankers’ Hours After Overwork Outcry
Boeing Union Goes On Strike, Halting 737 Production
Harris Struggling to Blunt Trump’s Edge on the Economy
Wall Street Turns Skittish on Eve of Rate Cuts
Suspected Trump Gunman Had Rifle With Scratched-Off Serial Number
U.S. Authorities Were Warned About Suspected Trump Gunman
The Fed Rate Cut is Here. Our Correspondent Explains What’s at Stake.
Big Rate Cut Forces Fed to Contend With New Obstacles
The Most Surprising New Gun Owners Are U.S. Liberals
Intel’s Fall From Global Chip Champion to Takeover Target
The Civil War Still Echoes in the South, Forcing Towns to Take Sides
Russia and U.S. Religious Conservatives See Common Foe in Africa: Gay Rights
The Vast Hezbollah Arsenal Awaiting Israel in Lebanon
Star FTX Witness Caroline Ellison Sentenced to Two Years in Prison
NYC Mayor Eric Adams Indicted on Federal Charges
How Eric Adams Became New York City’s First Indicted Mayor
Trump Plots Massive Shake-Up of Justice Department
Hezbollah Misjudged Israel’s Weakness and Iran’s Might
Israel Launches Raids Into Lebanon Ahead of Possible Ground Incursion
OCTOBER
Dockworkers Launch Strike at Ports From Maine to Texas
Vance Confident, Walz Uneven in Debate Heavy on Policy
Elon Musk Gave Tens of Millions to Republican Causes Far Earlier Than Previously Known
Riden Sidelined as Israel Reshapes Middle East
U.S. Wiretap Systems Targeted in China-Linked Hack
Google’s Grip on Search Slips as TikTok and AI startup Mount Challenge
Putin’s ‘Merchant of Death’ is Back in the Arms Business
Harris Allies Fear She is Struggling to Reach Working Class Voters
U.S. Frustrated by Israel’s Reluctance to Share Iran Retaliation Plans
Trump Pledges to End ‘Double Taxation’ of Americans Abroad
When the Hurricane-Relief Worker Turns Out to Be a Neo-Nazi
The Economy Under Trump vs. Biden
How the Election Results Will Raise or Lower Your Taxes
Scale of Chinese Spying Overwhelms Western Governments
Boeing Moves to Stabilize Finances With Stock Offering
Gender Gap is Defining Feature of Deadlocked Trump-Harris Race
A Second Trump Presidency Stands to Radically Remake World Trade
After Sinwar’s Death, Israel Has Stark Choice: Declare Victory or Keep Fighting
The Racial Identity of Americans is Rapidly Blurring. Politics Hasn’t Caught Up.
Boeing, Union Reach Deal to End Strike
Candidates Step Up Their Attacks After Trump Erases Harris’s Lead
How Beijing Recruited New York Chinatowns for Influence Campaign
Former Abercrombie CEO Mike Jeffries Charged in Sex-Trafficking Case
Trump Takes Narrow Lead Over Harris in Closing Weeks of Race
Elon Musk’s Secret Conversations With Vladimir Putin
Israel Strikes Back at Iran, Expanding War in Middle East
How Israel Pulled Off Its Largest-Ever Strike on Its Nemesis Iran
Economists Warn of New Inflaton Hazards After Election
Pentagon Runs Low on Air-Defense Missiles as Demand Surges
America’s Top Archivist Puts a Rosy Spin on U.S. History – Pruning the Thorny Parts
A Financier Penned a Crime Novel. Prosecutors Want to Know How Much Was Fiction.
NOVEMBER
Big Tech Sees AI Bets Starting to Pay Off
Harris and Trump Woo Americans Who Don’t Even Know if They Will Vote
Young Men Could Boost Trump to Victory – if They Show Up
America Heads to the Polls as Hard-Fought Race Comes to a Close
Trump Wins Pennsylvania, Putting Him on Brink of Presidency
Wall Street Salivates Over a New Trump Boom
Trump to Renew ‘Maximum Pressure’ Campaign Against Iran
How Barron Trump Connected His Father to the Manosphere
Deals and Deterrence: Trump’s Foreign Policy in a Dangerous World
Calls for ‘Jew Hunt’ Preceded Attacks in Amsterdam
Loyalty Is Common Thread as Trump Fills Foreign Policy, Immigration Jobs
A Drug Gang Stole 3 Tons of Gold in a Scam So Perfect It’s Still Going
Trump Sends Shockwaves Through Washington With Gaetz Pick
Smugglers Tell Migrants to Rush to U.S. Before Trump Takes Power
Trump’s Top Team Sets Stage for White House Power Grab
China’s Heavyweight Coast Guard Ships Bring Muscle to Sea Disputes
How Democrats Blew It on Inflation
Donald Trump Jr. Goes All-In on the Anti-Woke Economy
American Companies Are Stocking UP to Get Ahead of Trump’s China Tariffs
China is Building 30,000 Miles of High-Speed Rail–That It Might Not Need
Botched Gaets Nomination Shows Limits of Trump’s Hold Over GOP
7-Eleven, the Slurpee and a $47 Billion Takeover Battle
Palm Beach, a Democratic Pocket in Florida, Becomes MAGA Central
As Musk Assumes Deregulation Role, Tesla Racks Up Pollution Violations
Trump Pledges Tariffs on Mexico, Canada and China
Trump Returns to ‘Maximum Pressure’ as Era of Biden Alliances Ends
More Oil for Fewer Migrants: Trump is Urged to Make Deal With Venezuela
Buy Now Before Tariffs Hit, Retailers Are Telling Shoppers
Corporate America Launches Unorthodox Campaign to Gain Trump’s Attention
DECEMBER
Shoppers Fight Back as Retailers Crack Down on Returns
President Biden Pardons Son Hunter
Biden Pardon Threatens His Legacy – and Democrats’ Fight Against Trump
America’s Role Reversal: Working-Class Blacks Make Gains While Whites Fall Back
Murder at Dawn: A Top Executive’s Final Moments in Manhattan
Clues Left by a Killer Echo Widespread Anger at Health Insurers
How an Assassin Escaped One of the Most Surveilled Cities in the World
Syrian President Bashar al-Assad Flees as Rebels Take Damascus
Biden is Ceding Presidential Influence to Trump, and Some Democrats Are Furious
Suspect in UnitedHealth Killing Was Ivy Leaguer With Anticapitalist Leanings
UnitedHealth Exec Shooting Heightens Debate Over 3-D-Printed Ghost Guns
Netflix’s Extraordinary Parental Leave Was Part of Its Culture. That’s Over.
Trump Advisers Seek to Shrink or Eliminate Bank Regulators
The Week CEOs Bent the Knee to Trump
CEOs Want Trump to Change Course on Tariffs. He Isn’t Budging.
Why Musk Doesn’t Have Access to SpaceX’s Biggest Government Secrets
Assad’s Fall Upends the Middle East’s Largest Drug Empire
Ukraine Says It Killed Senior Russian General in Moscow Scooter Bombing
The Next Big Fed Debate: Has the Era of Very Low Rates Ended?
James Bond Outdueled Goldfinger and Dr. No. Can He Win a Battle With Amazon?
Congress Approves Revised Spending Plan to Avert Shutdown
America’s Private Prison Complex Gears Up for Trump Deportation Bonanza
Democrats Are Adrift as Trump Prepares to Take Power
House Ethics Report Says Gaetz Regularly Paid Women for Sex
The Big Companies Funding Trump’s Inauguration Despite Denouncing Jan. 6
Behind Closed Doors: The Spy World Scientists Who Argued Covid Was a Lab Leak
The Celebrity Activist Investor is Going Extinct
The Progressive Moment in Global Politics is Over
Giant Construction Site in the Saudi Desert is a Hellhole for Workers
Jimmy Carter, Former U.S. President, Dies at 100
Biden Exits Battling for His Legacy and Believing He Could Have Won